The seemingly harmless activity of tossing a few breadcrumbs or a bit of lettuce off your sandwich to a row of ducks wading off the shoreline is actually very harmful to those ducks, no matter how adorable it looks.
While some are learning that bread is a terrible food for all birds, even the most well-meant handful of seeds tossed to the waterfowl can and does contribute to disease, behavioural changes and even starvation in birds, according to a wildlife rehabilitator in the area.
"You're putting your lives in danger, and in jeopardy by causing health issues and possibly death as well," Debra Spilar, director and custodian at Procyon Wildlife Rehabilitation and Education Centre, said in a phone interview with Village Media.
Though one single person feeding a couple of ducks one time may not be detrimental to their health, the activity is common and happens daily because so many people partake.
"You get one person thinking they're doing a good thing, but that one person isn't just one person, it could turn out to be 1,000 people," said Spilar.
First and foremost, bread is bad for birds, stresses Spilar.
Birds eating bread can experience irregular feather growth that can make it impossible for them to fly and properly migrate, it leads to malnutrition because bread doesn't contain the nutrients the birds need to grow, develop and maintain their systems, and bread can mould in the water before it's eaten by a bird or turtle or fish, which gets sick from eating mouldy bread.
But even if people feed birds things they can eat, like lettuce, corn and oats, the act of regular human feeding is still harmful to the animals.
"They realize this is a food source for them, and they lose their ability to start hunting ... they rely on this food source," explains Spilar. "What happens in the winter time, when they've lost their natural ability to hunt and forage ... now they're not going to learn to eat greens and nutrients ... they'll starve."
The behaviour changes go beyond a loss of foraging and hunting skills. The birds can get aggressive in competing for a food source that's scattered in one place (like a boat launch) by people who stop by.
Habituating is a problem for all wildlife. It occurs when an animal is fed by a human enough to understand that a human is a food source and there's no negative consequences from that food source.
"Now, they think every person is going to feed them," said Spilar. "What happens when they go up to a person? For instance, if a raccoon was hand raised by somebody and now it's in a park and he goes up to somebody and he's pulling on their pant leg. He's not sick, he only wants food, but what does everybody think? Rabies. They call animal control and he's euthanized."
Seagulls get cursed for stealing ice cream from a cone or fries from fingers, but somewhere along the line, the gull learned that people provide food.
In Collingwood, it's technically illegal to feed wild animals, and that includes the ducks, geese and swans.
A Collingwood bylaw passed in 2016 prohibits feeding wildlife on public and private property, which does include tossing seeds, lettuce, bread and doughnut crumbs to the ducks in the Harbourview Park boat launch.
A sign posted at the boat launch stands as a reminder of the bylaw, and points out the dangers to people and animals of feeding waterfowl. And yet, it's a regular site at the Collingwood waterfront park.
"While feeding ducks, geese, and swans may seem like a harmless way to enjoy nature, this activity is prohibited and can have several negative consequences for both the birds and their environment," Adam Harrod, the town's acting manager of bylaw services, wrote in an email to Village Media.
"Generally speaking, individuals will stop the activity once they are educated on the harm that can be caused by intentionally feeding wild animals," said Harrod.
The bylaw prohibiting the feeding of wild animals was first enacted in response to "a number of reported human conflicts with coyotes and other wildlife," explained Harrod.
Though tossing some frozen peas to a couple of geese may not be seen as a dinner bell for coyotes, the province of Ontario's ministry of environment and energy explains that feeding wildlife can and does also attract what may be considered "unwanted" animals to your property.
In other words, animals spend a lot of time looking for food, and no skunk, raccoon or coyote seems to mind if the buffet was intended for a bunny or a duck.
A food source that attracts flocks of birds or other animals can also become a place where disease spreads farther and faster because animals are congregating in masses.
The Town of Collingwood consulted with the Ministry of Natural Resources and Forestry, other municipalities (many Ontario municipalities also have bylaws prohibiting the feeding of wildlife) and organizations like Coyote Watch Canada to inform the Collingwood wildlife feeding bylaw.
The local bylaw is enforced on a complaint basis with four enforcement actions last year and three this year. Harrod said officers focus on education when enforcing the wildlife feeding bylaw.
"The bylaw is designed to protect people, property, and animals by reducing the interactions that often lead to these conflicts." said Harrod. "By preventing the intentional feeding of wildlife, the town aims to maintain a safer environment for both residents and animals."
Backyard bird feeders are exempt from the town's wildlife feeding bylaw, but spilled seeds must be cleaned up.
Those bird feeders can still be harmful because they do become reliable food sources, so any gap in provision can be difficult for a bird or animal to adjust to. Bird seed can also attract other animals to a property.
The advice from Ontario's ministry of environment and energy is to appreciate wildlife from a distance, attract wildlife to your property by improving natural habitat and by protecting and preserving existing habitats, and to keep household waste, compost and pet food out of reach for wild animals.
To read the Town of Collingwood's wildlife feeding bylaw, click here.
